Reference note · Legal concepts and terminology
Suitability and appropriateness under MiFID II
Two distinct assessments with distinct functions: what MiFID II requires, and why the distinction matters in an investment dispute.
- Published:
- Last reviewed:
§ 1Two different assessments
Directive 2014/65/EU (MiFID II) distinguishes between the assessment of suitability and the assessment of appropriateness. Both are set out in Article 25 of the Directive and are further specified in Articles 54 to 57 of Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2017/565. These are binding EU rules. Under Article 16 of Regulation (EU) No 1095/2010, ESMA has issued guidelines on both assessments (ESMA35-43-3172 on suitability; ESMA35-43-2938 on appropriateness and execution only). Those guidelines are not legislation: they apply on a comply-or-explain basis to national authorities and firms.
The suitability assessment applies when a firm provides investment advice — personal recommendations to a client (Article 4(1)(4) of MiFID II and Article 9 of the Delegated Regulation) — or portfolio management. Under Article 25(2), the firm must obtain the necessary information about the client’s knowledge and experience, financial situation — including the ability to bear losses — and investment objectives, including risk tolerance, so that it can recommend services and instruments that are suitable for that client. Since 2 August 2022, the client’s sustainability preferences must also be taken into account (Article 54 of the Delegated Regulation, as amended by Delegated Regulation (EU) 2021/1253). For retail clients receiving advice, Article 25(6) requires a statement on suitability, in principle before the transaction.
The appropriateness assessment applies to other investment services. Under Article 25(3), the firm must ask for information about the client’s knowledge and experience in order to assess whether the service or product envisaged is appropriate. Where it considers that it is not, it must warn the client; where the client provides no or insufficient information, it must warn the client that it is not in a position to make that determination. A warning does not prevent the client from proceeding.
Article 25(4) allows a firm to execute or receive and transmit orders without an appropriateness assessment (“execution only”) only if cumulative conditions are met: the instruments are non-complex (the categories listed in Article 25(4)(a), completed by Article 57 of the Delegated Regulation), the service is provided at the client’s initiative, the client has been warned that no appropriateness assessment is made, and the firm complies with its conflict-of-interest obligations.
§ 2Why the qualification of the service matters
The first legal question in an investment dispute is therefore often which service was actually provided. A relationship presented as execution only may, on the facts, involve personal recommendations; the reverse is also possible. That qualification determines which duties applied. In Case C-604/11 Genil 48 and Comercial Hostelera de Grandes Vinos (judgment of 30 May 2013), the Court of Justice held, under the former Directive 2004/39/EC (MiFID I), that offering an interest-rate swap to a client may constitute investment advice where it is presented as suitable for that client or based on the client’s circumstances.
These conduct-of-business duties sit alongside information duties, including the general obligation to act honestly, fairly and professionally in accordance with the best interests of clients (Article 24(1) of MiFID II) and the obligation to provide appropriate information in good time (Article 24(4)), and, for packaged retail and insurance-based investment products, the key information document required by Regulation (EU) No 1286/2014 (PRIIPs).
§ 3From regulatory breach to civil liability
MiFID II is primarily addressed to firms and supervisory authorities. It does not itself lay down the civil consequences of a breach of its conduct rules. Article 69(2) requires Member States to have mechanisms under which compensation may be paid or other remedial action taken “in accordance with national law”, and in Genil 48 the Court held that it is for the legal order of each Member State to determine the contractual consequences of a failure to comply with the suitability and appropriateness rules, subject to the principles of equivalence and effectiveness.
Whether a breach gives rise to a civil claim, and under what conditions, is therefore governed by national law. A breach is not, by itself, compensation: the existence of damage and of a causal link between the breach and that damage must be established in each case.
§ 4National implementation: Spain and Belgium
In Spain, the MiFID II conduct rules are set out in Title VIII of Ley 6/2023 of 17 March 2023 on securities markets and investment services. Article 204 governs the suitability assessment, Article 205 the appropriateness assessment and Article 207 the exemption from the appropriateness assessment for execution-only services. Article 205(6) adds a national formal requirement for complex instruments: where the client has been warned that the product is not appropriate, or that its appropriateness could not be assessed, the contractual document must include, alongside the client’s signature, a handwritten statement to that effect in terms determined by the CNMV. Genil 48 itself arose from a reference by a Spanish court.
In Belgium, MiFID II was transposed mainly by the Law of 21 November 2017, which amended the conduct rules of the Law of 2 August 2002 on the supervision of the financial sector (Articles 27 to 28bis), and by the Royal Decree of 19 December 2017. In both countries, consistently with Genil 48, the civil consequences of a breach are determined by national private law.
§ 5Scope and status of this note
Verified on 18 November 2026 against the consolidated text of MiFID II on EUR-Lex (version of 6 June 2026) and the Delegated Regulation. The Commission’s retail investment proposal of 2023 (COM(2023) 279), which would amend these provisions, had not been published in the Official Journal at that date; it is therefore not taken into account. The Spanish provisions were checked against the consolidated text of Ley 6/2023 in the Boletín Oficial del Estado (update of 7 October 2026). The Belgian transposing texts are identified but not analysed article by article.
Sources and references
- [1]Directive 2014/65/EU (MiFID II), consolidated text of 6 June 2026 — Articles 4(1)(4), 24, 25 and 69(2)(opens in a new window)EU law
- [2]Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2017/565 — Articles 9 and 54 to 57(opens in a new window)EU law
- [3]Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2021/1253 (sustainability preferences), applicable from 2 August 2022(opens in a new window)EU law
- [4]ESMA, Guidelines on certain aspects of the MiFID II suitability requirements, ESMA35-43-3172 (final report of 23 September 2022)(opens in a new window)Supervisory authority
- [5]ESMA, Guidelines on certain aspects of the MiFID II appropriateness and execution-only requirements, ESMA35-43-2938 (final report of 3 January 2022)(opens in a new window)Supervisory authority
- [6]CJEU, Case C-604/11, Genil 48 SL and Comercial Hostelera de Grandes Vinos SL v Bankinter SA and BBVA SA, judgment of 30 May 2013(opens in a new window)Case law
- [7]Regulation (EU) No 1286/2014 (PRIIPs)(opens in a new window)EU law
- [8]Spain — Ley 6/2023, de 17 de marzo, de los Mercados de Valores y de los Servicios de Inversión, Articles 204, 205 and 207 (consolidated text, BOE update of 7 October 2026)(opens in a new window)National law
- [9]Belgium — Law of 21 November 2017 on the infrastructures of markets in financial instruments and transposing Directive 2014/65/EU(opens in a new window)National law
This content is general legal information. It is not legal advice and does not create a lawyer–client relationship.
Related content
Legal concepts and terminology
Causation and loss of a chance in financial disputes
Why the causal link is often the decisive question in investment and banking claims, and why loss of a chance is not a universal concept.
Financial Liability · Investor Protection
Published Official sources: 8
Legal concepts and terminology
Cross-border financial disputes: jurisdiction and applicable law
Which courts may hear a cross-border financial dispute, and which law governs it — the EU framework and its limits.
Financial Liability · Banking Disputes · Investor Protection
Published Official sources: 13
Legal concepts and terminology
Supervision is not compensation: supervisory duties and civil liability
Why a supervisory failure does not automatically give an individual a right to compensation — and why the question nevertheless remains a legal one.
Financial Regulation & Supervision · Financial Liability
Published Official sources: 5