Skip to content

Financial Law · III

Financial Regulation & Supervision

Supervisory institutions, their powers and the legal limits of their authority.

Financial supervision in Europe is multi-layered. National authorities such as the FSMA and the National Bank of Belgium operate alongside the European Central Bank, the European Banking Authority and ESMA, within a body of EU financial legislation.

Scope

  1. 01FSMA
  2. 02National Bank of Belgium
  3. 03European Central Bank
  4. 04European Banking Authority
  5. 05ESMA
  6. 06Relevant EU financial legislation
  7. 07Regulatory duties and institutional powers
  8. 08Financial compliance and governance
  9. 09Supervision and legal accountability
  10. 10The legal limits of regulatory authority

Legal frameworks

Spanish law, Belgian law and the EU law that applies to both, followed by the comparative questions that arise. Where EU rules are harmonised, national differences are not presumed.

ESSpain
Supervision is organised by sector. The CNMV supervises securities markets and investment services. The Banco de España supervises credit institutions, including their conduct towards clients. The DGSFP supervises insurance and pension funds.
BEBelgium
Belgium follows a twin-peaks model. The National Bank of Belgium is responsible for prudential supervision, and the FSMA for financial markets and conduct towards clients. Article 68 of the Law of 2 August 2002 limits the civil liability of the FSMA to fraud and gross negligence.
EUEuropean Union
The European Central Bank directly supervises significant credit institutions in the euro area within the Single Supervisory Mechanism (Regulation (EU) No 1024/2013). The EBA and ESMA contribute to the single rulebook and to supervisory convergence. Conduct supervision remains national.
Comparative questions
Similar labels do not mean identical competences. Whether an authority can be held liable, and under which conditions, depends on the national regime. A supervisory breach does not in itself create an individual right to compensation.

Questions the analysis asks

  • Which authority is competent, on which legal basis, and for which institution?
  • Is the relevant instrument a binding rule, a guideline or a supervisory expectation?
  • Which review mechanisms exist for supervisory decisions?
  • Does the supervisory rule also protect individual interests under the applicable private law?

Reference notes in this area

Legal concepts and terminology

Supervision is not compensation: supervisory duties and civil liability

Why a supervisory failure does not automatically give an individual a right to compensation — and why the question nevertheless remains a legal one.

Financial Regulation & Supervision · Financial Liability

Published Official sources: 5

Comparative studies

Who supervises whom? Supervisory architecture compared

A comparative map of the principal financial supervisory authorities in Spain, Belgium and the European Union, with comparative references to France, Germany and the United Kingdom.

Financial Regulation & Supervision

Published Official sources: 17